Australian music leaders reject special treatment in reported AI copyright proposal
The permit proposal remains unconfirmed. Industry leaders say separating music from films and television would also be difficult to implement.
Loading page…
The permit proposal remains unconfirmed. Industry leaders say separating music from films and television would also be difficult to implement.
Listen to this story
A reported Australian plan would let AI companies pay for training access to local content while potentially exempting music, but music and writing leaders reject a sector-by-sector deal. They argue it would divide creators and leave unanswered how a film or TV show containing music, video and scripts could be treated. The proposal remains unconfirmed: the government declined to comment, and the Guardian could not verify its details. The dispute leaves commercial negotiations and broader creator protections at the center of the policy debate.
The Australian Financial Review reported on Thursday that the government was considering paid training permits with a possible music exemption; the proposal is not confirmed policy.
ARIA chief executive Annabelle Herd said she had not known of the proposal and would have called it unnecessary and unworkable.
Anthropic has suggested allowing content collection unless rights holders object, while OpenAI told a parliamentary committee it could support a creator fund.
Australian music and writing-industry leaders have rejected a reported AI copyright proposal that could protect music while opening other Australian content to paid training access. Their response puts solidarity between creative sectors at the center of the dispute: music representatives say they will not accept special treatment that leaves other creators behind.
The Australian Financial Review reported on Thursday that the government was considering a copyright change allowing AI companies to buy permits to train on Australian content, with music potentially exempted, according to the Guardian. That would give developers a paid route to training material while potentially treating one creative sector differently.
The proposal is not confirmed government policy. The Guardian could not independently verify its details, and the government declined to comment. People in the creative community gave differing accounts: one involved in government copyright discussions had heard some details, while others had not and doubted the government would seriously consider it.
Annabelle Herd, chief executive of the Australian Recording Industry Association, said she had been unaware of the proposal before Thursday. Had the industry been consulted, she said, it would have called the scheme unnecessary, unworkable and designed around AI companies’ commercial interests rather than creators’ protection.
Our position is unchanged: we stand with the rest of the creative and media industries.
Annabelle Herd, ARIA chief executive, speaking to Guardian Australia
Australian Writers’ Guild chief executive Claire Pullen also rejected a split between sectors. She said creative groups had worked with government on a model since 2024 and had invited AI companies to negotiate for years. In her account, the technology companies had refused even to talk about the solutions creators had developed.
The Media, Entertainment & Arts Alliance, the union representing writers and creatives, said it was alarmed by the reported proposal. It demanded that protections promised by Prime Minister Anthony Albanese apply to all creative sectors, not only musicians.
Herd and Pullen raised a practical objection as well as a collective one. Films and television combine music, video and screenwriting, each involving copyrighted material. They questioned how a training scheme would handle those works if only the music were exempt. Their objection concerns how a sector-specific exception could operate inside a single work containing several kinds of protected content.
AI companies have sought other routes to training access. Anthropic suggested conditional approval to collect content unless a rights holder objected. OpenAI told a parliamentary committee it would potentially support paying into a fund for creators. Some AI companies have also argued that individual licensing agreements are too difficult under existing copyright law.
Senior government figures have meanwhile sharpened their criticism of current arrangements. Industry Minister Tim Ayres said on Tuesday that “the status quo is no good” for creative workers. Acting Prime Minister Richard Marles repeated that position on Thursday and told News24 that people were being ripped off.
Opposition politicians also challenged the reported music exemption. Shadow attorney general Michaelia Cash said it would divide rights holders. Senator David Pocock called it a “divide and conquer strategy” and noted that the joint select committee had not yet delivered its report to government.
Attorney General Michelle Rowland’s office said Australian creatives’ work was being used without consent or payment and promised strong protections. Its stated route remains commercial negotiation: a spokesperson said the government would continue pressing technology companies to strike deals with Australian artists.
Loading discussion...
Join the conversation
Explain whether solidarity is worth passing up a separate deal.
Be the first to share a perspective or an experience.
Reader comments
Newest comments first. Replies stay oldest first.