Judge lets memory price-fixing lawsuit against Samsung, SK hynix and Micron proceed
The plaintiffs point to parallel supply cuts and a shift toward AI memory. The chipmakers say they independently responded to the same market pressures.
Loading page…
The plaintiffs point to parallel supply cuts and a shift toward AI memory. The chipmakers say they independently responded to the same market pressures.
Listen to this story
Judge Noël Wise’s November 14 ruling keeps Samsung, SK hynix and Micron in a proposed class action over alleged DRAM supply coordination. The plaintiffs’ claims—including production cuts and a shift toward HBM—were deemed plausible enough to proceed, not proven. For AI hardware buyers, the case puts scrutiny on whether manufacturers’ focus on AI memory contributed to tighter DRAM supply and higher prices; the competing explanation is that each company acted independently amid strong demand.
The proposed class includes 17 individuals and small businesses alleging DRAM prices rose by as much as 500% in one year.
Plaintiffs cite production cuts from October 2022 through April 2023, planned DDR4 wind-downs, and limited capacity expansion.
The complaint also points to stricter customer vetting, rejected long-term contracts, shortage forecasts, and Micron’s closure of Crucial.
Samsung, SK hynix and Micron must keep defending a proposed class action accusing them of coordinating memory-chip supply restrictions. Judge Noël Wise denied their motion to dismiss, Tom’s Hardware reported, allowing plaintiffs to pursue allegations that parallel production decisions helped drive sharp price increases rather than simply reflecting shared market pressures.
Wise issued the ruling on November 14, according to 36Kr. The lawsuit involves 17 individuals and small businesses challenging the manufacturers’ conduct in DRAM, the memory-chip market at the center of the dispute. Their case rests on a pattern of business decisions they say restricted supply and raised prices.
The plaintiffs cite production cuts between October 2022 and April 2023, followed by what they describe as a coordinated pivot to HBM. That memory is used in AI computing hardware. They allege DRAM prices rose by as much as 500% in one year, tying their account of the shortage to decisions about what the manufacturers produced and how much supply they made available.
Their argument also reaches beyond those initial cuts. The plaintiffs say the three companies announced plans to wind down DDR4 production within a three-month span. They further allege the manufacturers failed to expand production capacity despite unusually high prices. In that account, the combination of reduced supply and a limited production response matters more than any single decision viewed alone.
Other conduct forms part of the same allegation: stricter customer-vetting procedures, refusals to sign long-term DRAM contracts, and statements projecting continued shortages. The plaintiffs also cite Micron’s decision to close its Crucial consumer-memory brand. These are elements of their argument about restricted supply, not separate findings that those actions were unlawful.
The chipmakers offer a different explanation for the similarities. They argue that each company made independent business decisions to maximize revenue during strong demand. In a highly concentrated market, they say, competitors face the same pressures and watch one another closely. Similar responses, under that explanation, reflect each manufacturer’s own interests rather than an agreement to restrict supply.
Their contentions are more akin to hawks flying in formation — an activity that hawks ordinarily do not do.
Judge Noël Wise, as quoted by Tom’s Hardware
Wise rejected the companies’ characterization of the lawsuit as a rerun of an antitrust case filed against the industry in 2018. She found the plaintiffs had presented new material making the alleged collusion plausible enough for the case to continue. Her hawks comparison challenged the defense’s explanation that the companies were merely watching one another and responding competitively.
That is a procedural victory for the plaintiffs, not a judgment that the manufacturers fixed prices. The ruling does not establish liability or settle whether coordinated restrictions, rather than independent business choices, explain the conduct being challenged. Both sides still have to present their evidence and arguments before the court reaches a decision on the dispute.
The manufacturers have until December 7 to respond to the original complaint. A case-management conference is scheduled for January 2027 to address how the litigation will proceed.
Loading discussion...
Join the conversation
Explain where sensible competition ends and a suspicious pattern begins.
Be the first to share a perspective or an experience.
Reader comments
Newest comments first. Replies stay oldest first.