KPMG says just 1% of surveyed insurance CEOs have seen measurable AI returns
Nearly two-thirds plan to devote 11% to 20% of their budgets to AI. Implementation costs are becoming a bigger obstacle as insurers target claims, underwriting and pricing.
Loading page…
Nearly two-thirds plan to devote 11% to 20% of their budgets to AI. Implementation costs are becoming a bigger obstacle as insurers target claims, underwriting and pricing.
Listen to this story
KPMG’s 2026 survey of 100 insurance CEOs at organizations with more than $500 million in annual revenue shows a gap between AI ambitions and demonstrated value: only 1% report measurable returns, while 82% rank AI among their top investment priorities. Most expect payback in one to three years, but rising implementation costs could complicate that timeline. The findings point to claims, underwriting and pricing as leading areas for expected value—not yet proven returns—and suggest execution across core operations will be the test.
The share of executives citing implementation costs as a challenge rose from 37% in 2025 to 48% in 2026.
While 77% report significant progress modernizing core operating models, only 3% say they are fully modernized across most core functions.
Claims improvements, underwriting and pricing optimization, and policyholder experience were selected as value drivers by 50%, 49%, and 47% of respondents, respectively.
Insurance executives are committing substantial budgets to AI before most can show a measurable return. KPMG’s 2026 Global Insurance CEO Outlook, released November 19, found that just 1% of respondents had achieved measurable returns. Yet nearly two-thirds plan to allocate between 11% and 20% of their budgets to AI over the next year.
The findings describe large insurance businesses, not the entire market. KPMG’s report covers 100 CEOs overseeing organizations with annual revenue above $500 million, including insurers, reinsurers and brokers. They participated in the wider CEO Outlook survey conducted from August 11 through September 21, 2026. The results capture executives’ accounts of performance and their plans for investment, hiring and business change.
AI ranks as a top investment priority over the next three years for 82% of respondents. The spending plans are substantial: 64% intend to direct 11% to 20% of their budgets toward the technology during the next 12 months. Those are planned allocations, rather than a measure of money already spent or benefits already delivered.
Most executives place the payoff further out. Some 84% expect returns within one to three years, up from 67% in 2025, according to Insurance Business’s coverage of the findings. That expectation sits alongside growing concern about the expense of putting AI into operation.
Frank Pfaffenzeller, KPMG International’s global head of insurance, described the task as turning investment and confidence into sustained performance. He urged insurers to concentrate on tangible value for their businesses and customers while maintaining discipline through regulatory and economic pressures.
The survey identifies the core insurance activities where executives expect business improvements to create value. Asked to select their three most significant value drivers over the next three years, respondents put claims, underwriting and policyholder relationships near the top. These are expectations about opportunities, not measurements of returns already achieved.
Modernization remains unfinished. While 77% said they had made significant progress updating their core insurance operating models, only 3% considered their organizations fully modernized across most core functions. The distinction separates progress on changing the business from completing that change across its essential operations.
Matthew Smith, KPMG’s insurance strategy and transformation leader, said better processes, technology and data in claims, underwriting and pricing can directly affect efficiency, customer outcomes and performance. He described the next phase as moving beyond incremental improvements toward more connected operations that can deliver value at scale.
The investment push is accompanied by demand for employees with technical skills. Some 83% include recruiting AI and technology talent in their long-term workforce plans, compared with 54% in 2025. Yet 52% identify skills shortages as a leading workforce challenge. Overall, 86% expect their organizations’ headcounts to grow over the next three years.
Executives also face constraints beyond recruitment and implementation bills. Regulatory pressure is a leading threat to growth for 41% of insurance respondents, compared with 26% of CEOs across all sectors in the survey. Cybersecurity and data security are cited by 37%. These figures concern perceived business risks, rather than measured costs attributable to AI.
Those pressures have not erased confidence: 87% are optimistic about their own companies’ growth prospects over three years. The share expecting annual earnings growth of 5% to 9.99% doubled, from 15% in 2025 to 30% this year. That is a forecast for company earnings, not evidence of an AI payoff.
For employees, changes extend beyond hiring. Reinsurance News reported that 81% of respondents are adapting responsibilities, career structures and working arrangements for closer interaction with AI, up from 66% last year. The workforce transition is already under way, even while most executives still place measurable investment returns in the future.
Loading discussion...
Join the conversation
Explain when patience becomes a reason to rethink the investment.
Be the first to share a perspective or an experience.
Reader comments
Newest comments first. Replies stay oldest first.