New York drops no-bid AI phone-tracking deal but still seeks devices, NYCLU says
Cognyte can still compete for the purchase, according to the civil-liberties group. Opponents want the city to abandon the devices, not just change how it buys them.
Listen to this story
The audio brief
Story brief
3 key pointsNew York City is changing how it would procure an AI-equipped cell-site simulator, not abandoning the proposed capability. The NYCLU says the city dropped a sole-source contract with Cognyte and will seek competitive bids, leaving Cognyte eligible to compete. The switch does not resolve questions about FalcoNet’s undisclosed behavior-analysis functions, how often police obtain warrants, or how the NYPD reports and disciplines use; 44 groups have urged the mayor not to buy the devices at all.
- 01
The abandoned proposal was a three-year, $750,500 contract for Cognyte’s FalcoNet system; it had not been finalized.
- 02
The NYPD said only four Technical Assistance Response Unit members would operate the proposed system and described warrant requirements, including a 48-hour deadline after emergencies.
- 03
The NYCLU reported more than 1,000 NYPD stingray uses from 2008 through May 2015, and a Brooklyn court ruled warrantless use unconstitutional in 2017.
New York City has abandoned a no-bid deal for NYPD cellphone-tracking equipment, but not its effort to buy AI-equipped tracking devices, according to a November 20 commentary from the New York Civil Liberties Union. The group says the city will pursue open bidding instead, with the original vendor, Cognyte, still eligible to compete.
The October proposal
The dispute began with a proposed three-year, $750,500 sole-source contract for Cognyte’s FalcoNet system. In its October 24 report, the New York Daily News described the NYPD as poised to sign, while City Hall said it was reviewing the proposal. The city was then considering public comments before deciding whether to approve the contract; the purchase was not yet a completed deal.
FalcoNet is a portable cell-site simulator, often called a stingray. These devices imitate cellular towers, drawing connections from nearby phones and capturing their unique identification numbers. That reach is central to the privacy dispute: phones belonging to people who are not suspected of a crime can also be swept into the collection.
The equipment can be mounted on vehicles or drones, or concealed in a backpack. The NYPD’s proposed deployment was on department vehicles. Police already use other cell-site simulators to locate suspects and people who are missing or suicidal. A department spokesperson told the Daily News that FalcoNet best met its needs after it explored different devices.
A different buying process, not a retreat
Writing on November 20, NYCLU policy counsel Medha Raman and editorial manager Simon McCormack said public outcry prompted the city to scrap the Cognyte contract. They said the city simultaneously announced its intention to buy an AI-powered cell-site simulator through open bidding. Their account describes a change in procurement, not a decision to stop seeking the technology or exclude Cognyte.
The NYCLU’s objections extend beyond how the contract is awarded. It says FalcoNet’s behavior-analysis functions remain unclear, including what behavior is analyzed and how. Daniel Schwarz, the group’s senior privacy and technology strategist, had raised the same concern about undisclosed AI capabilities in the October Daily News article.
Police safeguards face a transparency challenge
When defending the original proposal in October, the NYPD described restrictions on both access and use. Those assurances were tied to the proposed FalcoNet purchase, rather than evidence of a system already deployed under that contract:
- Access: Only four members of the Technical Assistance Response Unit would operate FalcoNet, using laptops on a closed, stand-alone network.
- Warrants: Officials said investigations require a warrant first. In emergencies, officers must document the circumstances and obtain a warrant within 48 hours.
- Content: The department said it would not use FalcoNet to listen to calls or collect information such as texts from phones unrelated to investigations, or share such data with other agencies.
Public accountability remains a separate issue. The NYPD does not publish case-by-case reports on cell-site simulator use, the Daily News reported. Eleni Manis, research director at the Surveillance Technology Oversight Project, argued that this makes it difficult to hold the department accountable for whom it targets. The NYCLU likewise questions how often warrants are obtained and how policy violations are disciplined.
That distrust has a history. The NYCLU’s 2016 disclosure found more than 1,000 NYPD stingray uses between 2008 and May 2015, without a written policy and almost always without warrants. A Brooklyn state court ruled in 2017 that the department’s warrantless use was unconstitutional, according to the group.
Opponents are now asking for more than competitive bidding. The NYCLU says 44 groups wrote to the Mamdani administration the week before its commentary, urging the mayor not to acquire the AI-equipped devices at all.
Sources
- nyclu.orgThe NYPD Wants to Use AI-Powered Stingrays (aka Cell-Site Simulators) Against New Yorkers
- nydailynews.comNYPD in negotiations to use new AI-driven technology that will make it easier to track cell phones
Reader comments
Newest comments first. Replies stay oldest first.