FTX’s former Anthropic investment would be worth an estimated $35 billion at the valuation expected for the AI company’s stock-market debut, The New York Times reported November 16. But the bankruptcy estate sold it for $1.34 billion in 2024. That gap has sharpened a dispute over whether recovering customers’ money should have meant waiting for a bigger return.
The Times, in new reporting by David Yaffe-Bellany that includes conversations with Sam Bankman-Fried from prison, says Anthropic is expected to go public this week at a $1.4 trillion valuation. Its $35 billion estimate accounts for dilution—the reduction in an investor’s ownership percentage as more shares are issued. It is a hypothetical value, not proceeds from a completed offering or a holding FTX still owns.
From an early AI bet to a bankruptcy asset
Bankman-Fried committed $500 million in late 2021 for a 13.5% stake in Anthropic. The company announced the investment from him and two FTX colleagues in April 2022. By November that year, FTX had collapsed after a run on deposits exposed an $8 billion hole in customer accounts. Bankman-Fried surrendered control, leaving turnaround executive John J. Ray III to oversee the bankruptcy.
Ray’s team faced a scattered collection of assets, including digital coins, Bahamas properties and stakes in other companies. Its task was to raise money to repay customers. The Anthropic holding became a contested part of that effort: some customers wanted the estate to retain it rather than turn it into cash.
The estate ultimately sold the shares to a few dozen investors for about $30 apiece, according to court filings cited by the Times. Buyers included an entity linked to Emirati investment fund Mubadala, the Ford Foundation and trading firm Jane Street. The sale returned more than the original investment, but transferred any subsequent gains—or losses—to those buyers.
The estate says the transaction was court-supervised and achieved market value at the time. Its spokesman emphasized that customer funds had been invested without consent and that nobody could know which investments would succeed. Lindsey Simon, a professor at Emory University School of Law, told the Times that selling was reasonable under the circumstances.
At the time, there was no news about an I.P.O.
Lindsey Simon, Emory University School of Law, speaking to The New York Times
Repayment is not the same as recovering the upside
The argument over Anthropic sits alongside a separate frustration with how customer claims were calculated. In May 2024, the estate announced that creditors were set to receive as much as $1.18 for every dollar lost. But claims were pegged to cryptocurrency values when FTX failed, during a deep market slump—not to the later value of the coins customers had held.
Sunil Kavuri, an FTX customer who testified at Bankman-Fried’s sentencing, told the Times he wished the estate had held the Anthropic shares. He also stressed that customers had never authorized Bankman-Fried to use their money. His objections distinguish dissatisfaction with the estate’s decisions from any defense of the conduct that put those assets into bankruptcy.
Bankman-Fried has used the Anthropic investment to support his argument that FTX had enough resources to repay users. But the eventual success of investments did not undo his fraud: he was convicted on seven counts of fraud and conspiracy and sentenced to 25 years. The missing customer money had financed investments alongside real estate purchases and political donations.
Ray’s response draws that boundary explicitly: Bankman-Fried misappropriated and gambled with customer money. A successful AI investment does not change whose money was put at risk.
Reader comments
Newest comments first. Replies stay oldest first.