Paul Schrader embraces AI filmmaking despite fears it can imitate his scripts
In a new Guardian interview, the filmmaker describes a collaboration with Fable and dismisses Hollywood’s ability to hold back synthetic performers.
Loading page…
In a new Guardian interview, the filmmaker describes a collaboration with Fable and dismisses Hollywood’s ability to hold back synthetic performers.
Listen to this story
Schrader is collaborating with San Francisco-based AI film studio Fable on *The Doors of Perception*, a horror-thriller that will use generated imagery for psychedelic visions. The move follows an experiment in which AI output seemed to him to imitate his writing; his belief that it had learned from all his scripts was not verified. He is also testing synthetic actors, while studio-contract rules and Oscar eligibility restrictions create distinct limits on their use. Schrader argues that profitability, rather than those restrictions, will determine whether AI performers spread.
The script experiment progressed from ten premises to a three-act structure and a breakdown of more than 40 scenes before Schrader stopped at the scripted scene.
Schrader said he screen-tested AI actors and attributed actors’ refusal of roles in *Three Guns at Dawn* to his turn toward AI characters.
SAG-AFTRA’s studio deal requires AI performers to offer significant additional value over live actors; the Academy separately barred AI actors and screenplays from Oscar wins this year.
Paul Schrader says an AI scriptwriting experiment frightened him with its imitation of his style. He is moving ahead with AI filmmaking anyway. In an interview published by the Guardian on November 21, the Taxi Driver screenwriter described plans for AI-generated hallucinations in a horror-thriller, alongside experiments with synthetic actors and doubts about Hollywood’s resistance.
Speaking to the Guardian’s Robert Booth, Schrader described starting with a request for a good premise for a Paul Schrader script. The system returned ten. He judged five good and three comparable to ideas he might have developed himself. He chose one and asked for a three-act structure, which he said took about ten minutes.
Next came a scene-by-scene breakdown running to more than 40 scenes. Only when he asked the system to turn the first scene into script format did the exercise become alarming. Schrader said it reproduced his manner of writing, including the clipped stage directions. He stopped the experiment and walked away from the table.
He inferred that the system had ingested every script he had written. That was Schrader’s explanation for the resemblance, not a verified account of its training data. His assessment of the output was personal, too: this was a writer describing recognition and fear, rather than an independent test of screenplay quality.
I realised it could write a Paul Schrader script. I got scared. I walked away from the table.
Paul Schrader, speaking to the Guardian
That reaction has not stopped his production plans. Schrader is collaborating with San Francisco-based AI film studio Fable on The Doors of Perception, a forthcoming horror-thriller built around psychedelic hallucinations. They are integral to its plot: two brothers pursue their mother’s killer, believing they can track the murderer by getting inside the psychedelic trip.
The project follows Schrader’s own experience taking ayahuasca at a two-week retreat in Costa Rica. He said he took it eight times but was disappointed not to experience visual hallucinations. For the film, he will instead rely on the collaboration with Fable to imagine those visions. The script includes an AI version of an ayahuasca ceremony in the Peruvian jungle.
Schrader also described accepting a suggestion from the AI about how to depict the ceremony. When the scene reached vomiting and visions, he said the system recommended discretion rather than graphic imagery. He agreed with that advice and called it a “conscious artistic choice”—his interpretation of the exchange, not evidence that the system was conscious.
His interest extends beyond generated imagery. Schrader said he has screen-tested AI actors and believes an entire film could be made with them. In September, he said he was turning to AI characters for Three Guns at Dawn, about three Black criminal brothers, after Black actors declined the roles, according to his account.
That position runs against restrictions described in the interview. SAG-AFTRA’s deal with major studios requires producers to show that an AI performer brings “significant additional value” compared with a live actor. The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences also barred AI actors and screenplays from winning Oscars this year. These are different barriers: one concerns using performers, the other awards eligibility.
Schrader dismissed the union’s effort as desperation. For him, the deciding force is money: if AI characters prove profitable, he doubts SAG-AFTRA can stop their use. He likened its restrictions to a fence that AI would plough through “like a bulldozer”.
Loading discussion...
Join the conversation
Explain what would make that choice fair.
Be the first to share a perspective or an experience.
Reader comments
Newest comments first. Replies stay oldest first.