Trinity’s philosophy department bans AI, including brainstorming and editing
The October policy reaches well beyond AI-written essays. Faculty cite risks to independent thought, while the college maintains access to AI tools.
Loading page…
The October policy reaches well beyond AI-written essays. Faculty cite risks to independent thought, while the college maintains access to AI tools.
Listen to this story
Trinity College’s philosophy department adopted a rule in October 2026 that bars deliberate AI use at every stage of coursework, including reading summaries, brainstorming, research, editing and writing. To address the difficulty of verifying take-home work, professor Shane Ewegen has replaced out-of-class writing with handwritten, in-class exams, even though philosophy papers can run 10 to 20 pages. The policy is a department decision, not a campuswide ban: Trinity supports faculty setting course rules and maintains access to college-supported AI tools.
All six philosophy faculty supported the rule, citing concerns about independent reasoning and increasingly uniform student writing; these are faculty observations, not study findings.
Forty faculty members signed a separate letter urging Trinity to divest from AI companies and suspend campuswide AI use, but the college declined.
Ewegen said professors at Fordham University and the University of Denver expressed interest in the policy; neither institution was reported to have adopted it.
Students in Trinity College’s philosophy courses cannot deliberately use AI even to brainstorm ideas or edit their own writing. The Hartford college’s department adopted the rule in October 2026, the Hartford Courant reported November 17. Its faculty argue that AI assistance undermines the independent thinking and writing their courses are meant to develop.
The policy prohibits deliberate AI use in philosophy courses in any capacity. It does not draw a line between asking a system to produce a finished assignment and using it for smaller steps along the way. The prohibited practices cover work before, during and after drafting:
Shane Ewegen, a philosophy professor who helped lead the effort, said all six department faculty agreed that AI threatens students’ development of critical-thinking skills. Their objection concerns the process of learning, not only whether a student submits work written by a machine. Ewegen emphasized students’ ability to reason for themselves and clarify their thoughts through writing.
Assistant professor Carmen De Schryver described students deferring to AI rather than risking an opinion of their own. She also said student writing had become more uniform, both in the views expressed and the language used. These are the faculty’s classroom observations and judgments about AI’s effects, rather than findings from a study of the ban.
part of the point in issuing a statement like this, despite the problems of enforcement, is to compel the students into taking a long, hard look at this technology, and what it really does for them, and what it really takes from them.
Shane Ewegen, Trinity College philosophy professor, speaking to the Hartford Courant
Ewegen acknowledged that a prohibition cannot by itself ensure students avoid AI outside class. He said he had eliminated out-of-class writing assignments because he could not see how to ensure students completed them without the technology. His students now take in-class, handwritten exams instead.
That is a substantial change for courses in which, Ewegen said, papers of 10, 15 or 20 pages are not unusual. He described AI use as ranging from generating an initial idea to editing a paper or writing it entirely. His assessment change addresses the difficulty of knowing how take-home work was produced; the department’s policy states what assistance is forbidden.
Trinity’s institutional position leaves room for that prohibition without extending it across campus. Its official AI guidance says faculty decide whether and how AI fits their courses and research. The college also says everyone at Trinity has access to college-supported AI tools, and describes its approach as neither retreating from the technology nor adopting it uncritically.
The disagreement has already reached the administration. At the semester’s start, 40 faculty members signed a letter Ewegen sent asking Trinity to divest from AI companies and suspend AI use campuswide. Ewegen said the college declined. He said he strongly disagreed with its approach but appreciated its desire to preserve academic freedom.
In an October letter to faculty, President Dan Lugo and Provost Sonia Cardenas argued that Trinity must prepare students for a world with AI. They said students, faculty and staff should have access to secure platforms. College spokesperson Andrea Cuevas likewise said students need the knowledge and judgment to use AI effectively, while critical thinking, creativity and ethical reasoning remain central to their education.
The departmental policy has drawn inquiries beyond Trinity. Ewegen said professors at Fordham University and the University of Denver contacted him to express interest—not that either institution had adopted the same rule.
Loading discussion...
Join the conversation
Explain where you would draw the line between assistance and outsourcing thought.
Be the first to share a perspective or an experience.
Reader comments
Newest comments first. Replies stay oldest first.