U.S. Catholic bishops have adopted restrictions on investments in certain AI companies, putting financial rules behind their concerns about human dignity. But the reach is narrower than a churchwide investment ban: the updated guidelines bind the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops itself, while other Catholic institutions can choose whether to follow them.
The bishops approved the changes at their November 18 fall meeting in Baltimore. In its November 19 announcement, the conference recorded 217 votes in favor, none against and one abstention. The Socially Responsible Investment Guidelines were last updated in 2021; this revision adds a dedicated section on artificial intelligence.
Dioceses, religious communities and other Catholic organizations may apply the guidelines to their own corporate-responsibility policies. The conference does not oversee their adherence. Archbishop Shelton Fabre, whose committee developed the update, told Religion News Service that many dioceses and some other Catholic organizations already follow the guidelines, even though only the conference is bound by them.
Which AI activities rule out investment
The exclusions target specified uses of AI rather than all companies developing the technology. Religion News Service’s account, published by America, describes restrictions spanning weapons, consumer manipulation, surveillance and applications that conflict with Catholic teaching on reproduction and genetics.
- Weapons and targeting: The conference cannot invest in companies creating autonomous weapons or automated targeting systems for military, security or immigration enforcement without meaningful human oversight.
- Manipulative design: Investment is prohibited in companies designing AI to be addictive or manipulative, or to harm the mental health of young or vulnerable people.
- Surveillance: Restrictions cover companies creating surveillance technology that fails to protect human life and dignity, reinforces bias or prejudice, or violates reasonable expectations of privacy.
- Genetics and reproduction: The rules exclude companies using AI for genetic manipulation or reproductive technologies prohibited by Catholic doctrine.
As society addresses the reality of AI and emerging technologies, it's vital that we engage actively as stewards and shareholders to uphold the dignity of the human person and the common good as we seek to build a better world.
Archbishop Paul S. Coakley, USCCB president
Using ownership to press for changes
Exclusion is only one part of the policy. The guidelines also call for shareholder advocacy: using the conference’s position as an investor to influence corporate behavior. The bishops want AI companies to prevent deepfakes and disinformation, block pornography, and promote privacy, workers’ rights and environmental protection.
That strategy also seeks to deter companies from using AI in decisions about rationing healthcare or insurance claims. These are goals for influencing companies through ownership, distinct from the activities listed as grounds for barring investment. The update therefore sets out both where the conference should withhold investment and where it hopes to press for change as a shareholder.
The conference describes three complementary approaches to ethical investing: do no harm, actively seek change and promote the common good. It draws that framework primarily from Mensuram bonam, a Vatican document released in 2022. The revision also introduces shareholder-advocacy policies for companies with indirect connections to activities the Church considers morally illicit.
AI is part of a larger investment-policy revision. The same update adds sections on private prisons and detention facilities, and food security, while offering guidance on cryptocurrencies and prediction markets. It also strengthens expectations for regular reporting by the people managing the conference’s investments. Those managers now have the revised guidelines to apply to the USCCB’s portfolio.
Reader comments
Newest comments first. Replies stay oldest first.