Utah creates student AI task force, with membership still pending
The advisory group will bring classroom experience into state decisions. Students behind the effort differ on how much AI assistance supports learning.
Loading page…
The advisory group will bring classroom experience into state decisions. Students behind the effort differ on how much AI assistance supports learning.
Listen to this story
Utah’s State Board of Education has created a student advisory task force as it develops classroom AI policy, but students had not yet been appointed as of a November 16 report. The group is meant to inform policy discussions and student-led activities, not signal consensus on AI use. Its advice will feed into work required by HB273, while the board’s ability to recruit students beyond its existing advisory council will test whether the process captures a broader range of views.
The task force is expected to meet about four times per school year, alternating between in-person and virtual meetings.
HB273 requires model classroom technology and AI policies, plus core computer science standards covering appropriate use, privacy, security, and ethics.
Rahul Nair proposed the task force after seeing little student representation in Utah’s school AI framework; Kennedy Mickelson later joined the effort.
Utah has approved a student task force to advise its education board on classroom AI, but its membership remains unfinished. SmartBrief reported on November 16 that students had not yet been assigned to the group, approved in October. The initiative gives students a formal advisory role without assuming they agree on where AI belongs.
The Artificial Intelligence Student Task Force sits under the Utah State Board of Education’s existing Student Advisory Council. Its role is to offer input on AI discussions, potential policies and student-led activities. It is expected to meet roughly four times each school year, alternating between in-person and virtual meetings.
The effort has a concrete policy backdrop. HB273, signed by Gov. Spencer Cox, requires the board to create model policies for technology and AI in public school classrooms. It also requires AI standards within core computer science standards, covering appropriate use, privacy, security and ethical interaction.
Students helped build the route into those discussions. KSL reported that Rahul Nair, a Skyline High School senior, noticed little student representation while reading Utah’s school AI framework. His initial idea was a survey. Working with educators and state AI specialist Matt Winters, he wrote a task force charter and presented the proposal at education events and before the board.
Hillcrest High School senior Kennedy Mickelson later joined the effort. Both students wanted a voice in policy, but their views show why consulting students is not the same as collecting endorsements for wider AI use.
Nair told KSL he uses AI to find studies and generate practice math problems. He worries schools could become too restrictive, but favors clear limits. One teacher labels assignments by the amount of AI assistance allowed, including a level that permits none. Nair said that clarity could help students use the tools responsibly.
Mickelson also uses AI, including for physics. She described asking it to explain one problem, trying the next herself, then having it check her mistakes. Her concern is that students can instead use the technology to finish assignments without developing the skills those assignments are meant to teach.
We're more in an environment now where, if you want, you can just not struggle at all and you can get through that class
Kennedy Mickelson, speaking to KSL
Her proposed boundaries are tighter for younger children: she would severely limit AI use below about age 13, introducing it more as a tutoring tool as students get older. She also wants policymakers to recognize students who avoid AI because of concerns about creativity, privacy, the environment or learning.
Recruitment presents another test. Board vice chair LeAnn Wood told SmartBrief that reaching beyond the Student Advisory Council’s current 15 members could be a challenge. Students outside that group may have different interests and goals. Nair likewise wants participation from across Utah, rather than only the Salt Lake Valley.
Winters has encouraged students to find ways to involve more peers. Ideas include a hackathon or another collaborative, judged activity. Wood hopes the work will give students hands-on experience researching an issue, gathering evidence and explaining how policy affects their lives—not simply attending meetings.
The board’s response will matter as much as participation. Wood said the experiment would have failed if students offered recommendations or raised concerns and the board disregarded them.
Loading discussion...
Join the conversation
Explain where helpful assistance becomes a shortcut around learning.
Be the first to share a perspective or an experience.
Reader comments
Newest comments first. Replies stay oldest first.