YouTube restores musician’s video after AI-channel operator drops copyright claim
Two counter-notifications failed. Media Nov Records withdrew its complaint after a journalist intervened, but still asserted rights and threatened legal action.
Loading page…
Two counter-notifications failed. Media Nov Records withdrew its complaint after a journalist intervened, but still asserted rights and threatened legal action.
Listen to this story
Samantha Shokin’s 50-second recording of the Bulgarian folk song “Bre Petrunko” had drawn 125,000 YouTube views before a copyright complaint removed it; YouTube rejected her two counter-notifications. Media Nov Records withdrew the claim after 404 Media contacted the company, and YouTube restored the video about 24 hours later. The dispute remains unresolved: Media Nov says withdrawal does not waive any rights and says it intends to pursue legal proceedings, while the company did not identify which catalog work prompted the claim.
Media Nov told 404 Media it operates 500 YouTube channels and advertises automated takedowns, Content ID management, and AI-powered content recognition.
Those advertised tools do not establish what triggered the complaint against Shokin’s specific recording.
Media Nov said Shokin’s and distributor Loopmasters’ earlier messages went to spam; after requesting her recording evidence, it withdrew the complaint minutes later.
Musician Samantha Shokin’s own recording disappeared from YouTube after a copyright complaint from a company that says it runs 500 channels. Two attempts to challenge the removal failed. Her video returned only after Media Nov Records withdrew its complaint following questions from 404 Media, according to the publication’s November 16 investigation.
The dispute concerns Shokin’s 50-second performance of “Bre Petrunko,” a Bulgarian folk song. She recorded it during the pandemic and first uploaded it to SoundCloud. On YouTube, the recording accumulated 125,000 views over four years before she discovered its removal last month.
The immediate mechanism was a copyright removal request: Media Nov complained, and YouTube took down the video. Shokin tried to reverse that through two counter-notifications, formal challenges to the removal. YouTube rejected both and directed her to the claimant. Its last denial said it was unclear whether she had a valid reason to file.
Shokin said she had original recordings and expected that evidence to resolve the problem. Instead, emails and calls to Media Nov went unanswered. Loopmasters, a distributor already familiar with her recording, also tried to contact the company without success, she told 404 Media.
“Any human would agree with me that there’s something clearly wrong here that needs to be fixed, but I can’t get in touch with a human being,” Shokin said.
Samantha Shokin, speaking to 404 Media
Media Nov markets music distribution alongside rights management. Its website advertised automated copyright takedowns, YouTube Content ID management—a system for identifying music—and AI-powered content recognition. That describes its advertised tools, not a verified explanation of what triggered the complaint against Shokin.
The company told 404 Media it operates 500 YouTube channels and works with artists, creators and music partners. The outlet examined four pages managed by Media Nov, each containing hundreds of videos. Many used AI-generated imagery and music, with looping electronic tracks sometimes posted across multiple channels.
Shokin’s recording had already circulated beyond her own accounts. She said DJs traced samples of her voice to Loopmasters’ “Folk Legends” pack. After she contacted the distributor, it apologized and granted her royalties. That earlier resolution had left her with a commercial relationship involving the same performance later removed from YouTube.
After 404 Media contacted Media Nov, the company responded to Shokin and requested original audio, recording evidence and publication dates. It told the outlet that earlier emails from Shokin and Loopmasters had landed in spam.
Media Nov asserted that it held certain rights relating to the musical content. It distinguished rights in a composition or arrangement from rights in a particular recording, citing Bulgarian composer Philip Koutev’s work. Shokin disputed that explanation, saying the issue concerned her voice and performance. Media Nov did not answer 404 Media’s question about which work in its catalog triggered the notice.
Minutes after requesting her evidence, Media Nov withdrew the removal request. It said the video had not generated revenue or received views and that keeping the request active was unnecessary. YouTube confirmed reinstating the video after the withdrawal; it was back about 24 hours later.
Copyright lawyer Alfred Steiner told 404 Media that filing takedowns for rights a claimant does not hold can create liability, including damages and legal fees. But small creators may struggle to obtain a remedy when they lack the resources to go to court.
For Shokin, reinstatement did not bring a clean end to the dispute. Media Nov said its withdrawal did not waive any rights it might hold and stated that it intended to initiate legal proceedings.
Loading discussion...
Join the conversation
Explain how you would balance fast enforcement with a fair appeal.
Be the first to share a perspective or an experience.
Reader comments
Newest comments first. Replies stay oldest first.