Nicalis removes AI music from The Binding of Isaac after player backlash
Players traced tracks to Suno through audio-file metadata. The removal patch is live on PC, but Nicalis has not explained how the music entered the game.
Loading page…
Players traced tracks to Suno through audio-file metadata. The removal patch is live on PC, but Nicalis has not explained how the music entered the game.
Listen to this story
The fallout has exposed a disclosure and release-process problem as well as a dispute over AI-generated music: Repentance+’s Steam listing did not identify the tracks, and players found their origin by inspecting audio metadata. Nicalis removed the files from the PC build, but has not said who added them or why. Recent Steam reviews fell to 8% positive, while console players must wait for Microsoft, Nintendo and Sony to approve the submitted patch.
A Reddit user identified 14 music files in the special mode: seven full songs and related intro and ending versions.
Some files included Suno metadata, including a “made with suno” comment, a creation timestamp and an identifier.
Valve requires developers to disclose AI use in game development; Repentance+ had no such disclosure when players discovered the tracks.
Nicalis has removed undisclosed AI-generated music from The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+ after players uncovered evidence linking tracks to Suno and flooded Steam with negative reviews. Creator Edmund McMillen said on November 21, 2026, that he had not known the music was included. The removal patch is live on PC, with console versions awaiting rollout.
The controversy followed a November 19 update that included a Grand Theft Auto-themed run. Repentance+ also reached PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X/S and Nintendo Switch 2 that week, while existing PC players received a free update. The disputed music belonged to the special mode, rather than being identified as a replacement for the game's wider soundtrack.
Players could access the GTA-inspired version by entering the seed V1CE BSMT before starting a run. It featured special weapons and music, and its patch notes promoted a “crime-packed surprise.” According to a breakdown by Reddit user ShweetsStuff, the mode contained 14 music files: seven full songs, along with related versions such as introductions and endings.
ShweetsStuff's allegation rested on more than how the songs sounded. Some files contained Suno metadata—information stored alongside the audio—that named the music-generation tool and linked to Suno pages. Kotaku reproduced one file's comment field, which included “made with suno,” a creation timestamp and an identifier. The user also described how others could inspect the comments with tools such as VLC.
Woke up to a shit show, obviously I had no idea it featured generated music in the daily run, looking into how that happened and getting it removed, stay tuned
Edmund McMillen, creator of The Binding of Isaac, on X on November 21, 2026, as quoted by Kotaku
The Steam listing gave buyers no notice of AI-generated assets. Valve requires developers to disclose AI use in game development, but Repentance+ had no such disclosure when the music was discovered. That made the dispute about both the generated tracks and their unannounced inclusion in an existing game. Players were learning about the music's origins from another player's file inspection, not the store description.
By IGN's November 21 report, just 8% of recent Steam reviews were positive, putting Repentance+ in the storefront's Overwhelmingly Negative category. Reviews explicitly criticized the AI music. One player argued that adding AI content after purchase should be grounds for a refund; another accused Nicalis of adding “AI slop” while breaking an already-existing game.
The complaints were not limited to AI. Kotaku described frustration over bugs, latency and quality control that had been building before the discovery. A Steam review criticizing the generated music also complained about the number of bug fixes in the long-awaited update. The poor reception therefore included grievances about the game's condition, alongside objections to the newly discovered tracks.
Within hours of McMillen's response, Nicalis issued a patch confirming the “removal of generated music files.” It did not explain who added the tracks, why they were used or how they reached the release build. The studio said it was continuing to address new and old bugs, while McMillen encouraged players to submit issues to the developers.
For console players, submission is not yet availability: Nicalis said it had sent the patch to Microsoft, Nintendo and Sony. No date was given for those versions to go live.
Loading discussion...
Join the conversation
Explain whether removing the content afterward changes your answer.
Be the first to share a perspective or an experience.
Reader comments
Newest comments first. Replies stay oldest first.