SpaceXSI denies liability over sexualised Grok images, arguing they were clearly fake
Jess Asato wants permanent technical measures preventing manipulated images of her. The company disputes both liability and her entitlement to that order.
Listen to this story
The audio brief
Story brief
3 key pointsIn a defense dated October 29, SpaceX Super Intelligence LLC argues that the Grok-generated images of Jess Asato it left online were visibly fictional, so she had no reasonable expectation of privacy. The company also disputes data-protection claims, including on the grounds that it did not determine users’ prompts. Asato’s High Court case tests whether responsibility can extend to an AI system’s design and to lasting controls on what it can generate, not only to content already published.
- 01
SpaceXSI says it removed images that breached its terms, including a video depicting Asato being chloroformed and prepared for sexual assault.
- 02
Asato says the company rewrote prompts with graphic details, sourced images from across the internet, and published results from an account it controls; these are her assertions, not court findings.
- 03
She seeks an order requiring permanent technical measures to prevent Grok from generating manipulated images of her.
SpaceXSI says sexualised AI images it left online were too obviously fictional to breach a British lawmaker’s privacy. Jess Asato’s lawsuit challenges the system that enabled their creation. In a defence dated October 29, reported by Reuters on November 19, the company denies liability for alleged breaches of her privacy and data protection rights.
Asato, a Labour member of Parliament, brought the case at London’s High Court after users generated sexualised images of her using Grok. Her claims concern misuse of private information and breaches of data protection laws. She alleges that the way Grok was designed and trained enabled it to generate sexualised content.
The defendant, SpaceX Super Intelligence LLC, is part of Elon Musk’s SpaceX and was formerly called xAI, then SpaceXAI. Reuters describes the case as one of the first to test liability for the design of an AI system, making the company’s defence relevant beyond the disputed images themselves.
A privacy defence built around implausibility
SpaceXSI’s lawyers distinguish between content the company removed and images it kept available. They say it took down AI-generated images of Asato that breached its terms, including a video depicting her being chloroformed and prepared for a sexual assault. The company’s position is not that it left every disputed image untouched.
For the remaining images, the defence argues that reasonable viewers would recognise them as AI-generated, fictitious and implausible, rather than realistic depictions. On that basis, SpaceXSI says Asato had no reasonable expectation of privacy. Its argument turns on how a viewer would understand the content, not simply on whether the images depicted her.
The company separately disputes the alleged data protection breaches. Among its reasons, it says it did not determine the content of the relevant users’ prompts. That places users’ instructions within its defence, alongside the argument about the images’ fictional appearance. Both are SpaceXSI’s legal positions, rather than findings resolving Asato’s claims.
Asato challenges the bystander argument
In a November 19 statement, Asato said builders of powerful AI tools must take responsibility. She accused SpaceXSI of trying to have it both ways: acknowledging an active role in producing and publishing the material while denying legal responsibility. Her response challenges the company’s account of its role, not merely the conduct of the users entering prompts.
The company admits it built the AI model, rewrote user requests to add its own graphic details, pulled images from across the internet, and published the results from an account it controls
Jess Asato, in a November 19 statement quoted by Reuters
Those assertions about the model’s handling of requests and publication are Asato’s account, not court findings. They explain why her challenge reaches beyond the initial prompt: she alleges that Grok’s own design and training enabled the sexualised output.
The order would reach future generation
Asato is asking for more than removal of existing material. She wants a court order requiring SpaceXSI to implement effective and permanent technical measures ensuring Grok cannot create manipulated images of her. The requested protection is specific to her and would address what the system can generate, rather than only what remains available after publication.
SpaceXSI says Asato is not entitled to that order. The dispute therefore includes both responsibility for the images already generated and whether the company must put lasting technical restrictions in place for her.
Sources
- ca.finance.yahoo.comMusk's SpaceXSI denies liability in UK lawmaker's lawsuit over Grok images - Yahoo News Singapore
Reader comments
Newest comments first. Replies stay oldest first.