Raleigh tenant is evicted after rent extension she says came from landlord’s AI
The apartment complex says it is investigating. A North Carolina senator wants mandatory AI disclosures, while also questioning responsibility for the written extension.
Listen to this story
The audio brief
Story brief
3 key pointsA Raleigh tenant was evicted after Colony Townhome Apartments’ AI assistant, Olivia, emailed that her $3,934.17 rent could be paid on November 30; the complex has not yet explained how it will address the written extension. The case raises a practical question beyond AI disclosure: whether a landlord is accountable for a business commitment made in its name by an automated agent. North Carolina Sen. Jim Burgin says he will renew his stalled proposal to require AI-interaction disclosures, while also calling for human oversight of AI-assisted decisions.
- 01
Laura Mack said the November 8 emails did not identify Olivia as AI and appeared to come from the leasing office.
- 02
Mack received an eviction notice on November 16 and was evicted before the promised November 30 payment date.
- 03
Colony spokesperson Alfred Leach said Friday that the complex was gathering information and would provide an update the following week.
Laura Mack has lost her Raleigh home after receiving a written rent extension she says her landlord later blamed on AI. The apartment complex is investigating, and a North Carolina senator is renewing his push for AI disclosures. But his response also raises a separate issue: responsibility for a promise sent in the landlord’s name.
The exchange began November 8, when an email signed “Colony Townhome Apartments” asked Mack when she could pay $3,934.17 in overdue rent. She proposed the last day of the month. The reply that day was direct: “Paying on November 30, the last day of the month, works,” according to WRAL’s initial investigation by reporter Tolly Taylor.
Mack believed she was talking to someone in the leasing office. The messages contained personal information and referred to a problem in her bathroom. She told WRAL she thought the office was giving her extra time because a severe ceiling leak had taken almost two weeks to repair. That was her understanding of the exchange, not a reason confirmed by the complex.
On November 16, she received an eviction notice. Mack said she had received no communication between the November 8 emails and that notice. When she called the leasing office, she said, a leasing agent told her both messages had come from Olivia, the company’s AI agent, which had mistakenly approved the delayed payment.
She went to the Wake County courthouse Thursday morning to try to reverse the notice. WRAL’s follow-up reported that she was evicted that day. The development changed the immediate stakes: Mack was no longer only trying to keep the payment date she believed had been agreed upon; she had lost the apartment before that date arrived.
Colony had told residents about Olivia in December 2025, describing an assistant available around the clock for rent and maintenance questions. Its announcement included headings such as “Who is Olivia?” and “Why we’re excited.” WRAL reported that subsequent emails from Olivia were clearly marked, but the November 8 messages to Mack did not identify themselves as AI-generated.
WRAL reviewed the emails Mack supplied. One message acknowledged the hole in her downstairs bathroom ceiling and added, “I’m sorry you’re dealing with that.” The messages were signed “Best regards, Colony Townhome Apartments.” Mack said the personal detail helped convince her that a human employee was responding. Her account concerns both the missing AI label and the apparent authority of the sender.
I think notification is one thing, and I think liability is another.
North Carolina state Sen. Jim Burgin, speaking to WRAL
Burgin, a Republican representing Harnett County, told WRAL on Friday that he would continue pursuing consumer protections in the next legislative session. His proposed “Bot Bill” would require people to be alerted when speaking with or otherwise interacting with AI. He has introduced disclosure legislation in each of the past three years, but it has not advanced in the legislature.
His criticism went beyond labeling. Burgin said the November 8 email should have disclosed Olivia’s role, but also argued that the landlord would have to defend the written extension. “Before someone evicted that lady, they should have reviewed their documents,” he said. He called for a human role in overseeing business decisions made using AI.
The complex has now responded. Spokesperson Alfred Leach told WRAL on Friday that Colony was gathering information about the matter and would provide an update the following week. That statement did not explain how the complex would handle the payment-extension email. The promised update leaves its substantive response to Mack’s account still pending.
Mack acknowledged that the overdue rent was her responsibility, while insisting someone at the office take responsibility for the mixed messages. WRAL reported that she was staying in a hotel through the weekend as she worked out her next steps.
Reader comments
Newest comments first. Replies stay oldest first.